Talk:Cave of Threshing

I think it would make more sense to have the map name "Fampyr's Crypt" as the title of the page, that's what most people will see and be looking for. Naryoril (talk) 14:23, 12 May 2019 (UTC)
 * Fampyr's Crypt is a redirect page for this purpose. Although yes, it does make sense ("Fampyr's Crypt" will probably be seen more often by players), the page focuses on the interior and the location's contents. Location pages have always used the scene name from the game files and the map screen - that's just how it is. I have no clue why Obsidian chose two different names. I don't think that this makes finding the page any harder, but perhaps it should be made more obvious. Maybe something as simple as adding "(also Fampyr's Crypt)" could suffice? Macklin (talk) 14:53, 12 May 2019 (UTC)
 * Yeah, i think it should be made more obvious. In my case i found this page when i was looking for how to complete Mapping the Archipelago: Razai Passage, which is probably how most people find this page, as there isn't really anything else to do in this location. But the way the focus is on "Cave of Threshing" makes it more confusing than helpful to complete this quest in my opinion. In addition: if you haven't already been there and thus probably already done everything there is to do in this very small location with just 3 enemies (iirc), there is no way to know the name "Cave of Threshing", and even then, most people will probably never notice the name. Naryoril (talk) 15:02, 12 May 2019 (UTC)
 * Although I'm not particularly in favour of changing the page name (I lean towards being game-accurate and wiki-consistent wherever possible), I think that in this case it is indeed confusing. Especially when you're looking for a place called "Cave of Threshing", as it isn't labelled as such on the world map. Only when you make an effort to either open the map screen, look at the combat log, or happen to save while in the location will you actually find out the name of the interior. I think that as a sort of in-between, perhaps articles referencing the cave should instead link to "Fampyr's Crypt" where possible (e.g. on that quest page), as well the addition to the opening paragraph of this page that I mentioned. Macklin (talk) 15:29, 12 May 2019 (UTC)